9-year-old stabbed to death by 13-year-old brings attention to criminal juvenile court system

September 08, 2015   |   Brad Smith

VIDEO: Charlotte Criminal Lawyer Brad Smith of Arnold & Smith, PLLC answers the question “What is an expungement?”

A very sad case out of Michigan recently made headlines involving a 13-year-old boy on trial for murder. The case is especially tragic because the 13-year-old stands accused of killing a 9-year-old, stabbing him to death at a neighborhood playground.

The case garnered significant attention when it happened last year. The defendant was 12 at the time and has since been deemed an adult in the juvenile court system. Under Michigan law, this means that the boy, if convicted of murder, will serve out a sentence until he reaches 21 in the juvenile system, at which point he will be resentenced as an adult.

So far, a jury has been selected and preliminary matters are nearly complete. Experts believe opening statements will begin tomorrow and the case will progress the rest of the week. Two issues that will be central to the case involve the boy’s age and his mental health.

What’s the age of criminal responsibility in North Carolina?

In North Carolina, one year can make the difference between whether a young offender is sent to the juvenile justice system and receives help and hopefully makes a recovery, or is banished to the adult court system and receives only punishment. The law says that those between the ages of 6 and 12 who commit any offense are to remain in the juvenile court system, with no option to transfer the case to the adult system. This changes at 13, in North Carolina, 13 to 15-year-olds who commit certain felonies (B through E) begin in the juvenile system, but have an option to be transferred into the adult system depending on the particular facts of each case. For those 13 to 17-year-olds who commit A felonies, the law mandates that they be assigned to the adult justice system.

North Carolina has the unfortunate distinction of being one of only two states that prosecutes 16 and 17-year-olds as adults. This applies to all criminal issues, whether minor traffic violations or serious felonies. Many have urged legislators to have this increased to 18, something they say will better protect children from adult criminal records and from being placed in dangerous jails and prisons with older, more seasoned criminals. Giving adult criminal records to teens makes it that much more likely that the kids will become frequent flyers in the criminal justice system, introducing them to the system at a young age rather than placing them in the juvenile system and attempting to teach them tools to avoid recurrent problems.

Though some believe that older teens are sufficiently mature to handle adult criminal punishment, researchers appear to be coalescing around the idea that a teen’s brain still has a lot of growing up to do. Brain scans indicate that cognitive development does not finish until a person is around 25. Sixteen and 17-year-olds are far closer to children, mentally, than adults, despite their size or swagger. At this age, the children are still developing and changing and, as a result, are highly receptive to behavioral modification. Research has even shown that in states where teens are charged as juveniles, the adolescent crime rate actually decreases, with teens getting intervention and treatment to address the source of the problem rather than simply receiving punishment.

Blog Author Brad Smith is a Managing Member of Arnold & Smith, PLLC, where he focuses on the areas of criminal defense, DUI / DWI defense and traffic defense. Mr. Smith was born and raised in Charlotte. He began his legal career as an Assistant District Attorney before entering private practice in 2006. In his free time, Mr. Smith enjoys traveling, boating, golf, hiking and spending time with his wife and three children. Arnold & Smith, PLLC is a Charlotte based criminal defense, traffic violation defense and civil litigation law firm servicing Charlotte and the surrounding area. If you or someone you know need legal assistance, contact Arnold & Smith, PLLC at (855) 370-2828 or find additional resources here.


About the Author

Brad Smith

Term Expires 2023

Brad Smith

Term Expires 2023

J. Bradley Smith is a Charlotte native who graduated from Charlotte Country School in 1996. Thereafter, he attended and graduated from North Carolina State University with a degree in Political Science. After his undergraduate studies, he attended the Walter F. George School of law at Mercer University, obtaining his JD in 2004.

After obtaining his license to practice in law in August of 2004, Mr. Smith joined the Mecklenburg County District Attorney’s Office where over the course of nearly two years he prosecuted a variety of different misdemeanor and felony cases. While serving as an Assistant District Attorney, Mr. Smith attended and graduated from the Trial Advocacy Program at the National Advocacy Center in Columbia, SC.

In 2006, Mr. Smith entered private practice and for the last 15 years he has fought for individuals charged with crimes in both State and Federal Courts across North Carolina. He has also had the honor of arguing cases in front of the North Carolina Court of Appeals, the North Carolina Supreme Court, and the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond Virginia. Mr. Smith also frequently represents individuals in front of state administrative agencies. In developing an extensive criminal law practice and co-founding the law firm of Arnold & Smith PLLC, Mr. Smith has handled all types of state and federal criminal charges, including but not limited to murder, sex crimes, drug offenses, computer fraud, money laundering, wire fraud, tax fraud, conspiracy, financial crimes, embezzlement, assault, domestic violence offenses and DWI.  He also has extensive experience representing students, and teachers at schools and universities for sexual misconduct or Title IX violations.   

Mr. Smith also focuses his practice on Civil Rights cases. He has represented many plaintiffs including a North Carolina District Court Judge who have been injured by the negligent or intentional conduct of a law-enforcement officer, a government entity, or the employee of a government.

Mr. Smith has had several high-profile cases that have appeared in the news and he is frequently called upon by the medial to provide insight for topics pertaining to the criminal justice system in North Carolina. He has spoken at the Blumenthal Performing Arts Center and is a popular lecturer to various civic groups and area organizations.

He has been a member of the North Carolina Advocates for Justice for many years. He has served on the legislative committee and in 2019 was appointed to the Board of Governors.